The installment sales method is a significant tool for taxpayers selling a rental property at a gain, offering a way to spread tax liability over the period in which the sale proceeds are received. This method, while beneficial in many scenarios, comes with its complexities and considerations, especially when dealing with rental properties. This article delves into the nuances of the installment sales method, covering its automatic application, the option to elect out, depreciation recapture, and various other aspects critical to understanding and optimizing the use of this method for rental property sales.
- Automatic Application of the Installment Method – The installment sales method automatically applies to the sale of a rental property sold at a gain when at least one payment is received after the year of sale. This method allows the seller to defer recognition of gains over the period payments are received, rather than recognizing the entire gain in the year of sale. The gain on the sale is reported proportionally as payments are received, aligning the tax liability with the cash flow from the sale. The installment method doesn’t apply if the sale results in a loss.
- Electing Out of the Installment Method – While the installment method applies automatically when all sale proceeds aren’t received in the sale year, sellers have the option to elect out. This election must be made by the due date of the tax return for the year of the sale and is irrevocable without IRS consent. Electing out means recognizing the entire gain in the year of sale, regardless of when the payments are received. This might be advantageous in a year when the seller has lower income or expects tax rates to rise in the future.
- Depreciation Recapture – One of the critical considerations in the sale of a rental property is the recapture of depreciation. The portion of the gain attributable to depreciation deductions taken during the period the property was rented must be recaptured as ordinary income in the year of sale, regardless of the installment method. This recapture can significantly impact the tax liability in the year of sale, as it is not eligible for deferral under the installment method.
- Determining the Contract Price and Profit Percentage – The contract price in an installment sale is the total consideration received by the seller, less any mortgage assumed by the buyer. The gross profit percentage is then calculated as the gross profit (selling price minus adjusted basis) divided by the contract price. This percentage is crucial as it determines the portion of each payment considered taxable gain.
- Pros of an Installment Sale:
o Tax Deferral – The primary advantage is the deferral of taxes, allowing the seller to spread the tax liability over several years.
o Possibility of a Lower Tax Rate – Capital gains rates are based on a taxpayer’s adjusted gross income, so the tax rate could be less for some years during the installment collection period than in the sale year.
o Cash Flow Management – It provides a steady stream of income over time, which can be particularly beneficial for retirement planning or other long-term financial strategies.
o Potential Interest Income – Sellers can potentially earn interest on the deferred payments, increasing the overall return on the sale.
- Cons of an Installment Sale:
o Interest Rate Risk – If the seller finances the sale at a fixed interest rate, there’s a risk that interest rates will rise, and the seller will be locked into a lower rate.
o Possibility of a Higher Tax Rate – Capital gains rates vary based on a taxpayer’s adjusted gross income, so the tax rate could be more during the installment collection period than in the sale year. In addition, Congress could increase the rates and/or lower the income point at which the capital gains rate applies.
o Buyer Default Risk – There’s always a risk that the buyer may default on the installment payments, leaving the seller to deal with foreclosure or renegotiation.
o Depreciation Recapture – The requirement to recapture depreciation in the year of sale can result in a significant upfront tax liability.
o Taxation of the Down Payment – The down payment received in the year of sale is part of the total payments and is subject to the same gross profit percentage calculation as other payments. This means a portion of the down payment will be recognized as gain in the year of sale.
- Buyer Assumes Existing Mortgage – If the buyer assumes the existing mortgage on the rental property, the amount of the mortgage assumed is subtracted from the selling price to determine the contract price. This can reduce the seller’s immediate tax liability but also decreases the overall contract price, affecting the gross profit percentage.
Disposition of an Installment Note Before It’s Paid Off – Selling or otherwise disposing of the installment note before it’s fully paid off triggers immediate recognition of all remaining gain, potentially resulting in a significant tax liability in the year of disposition. This requires careful planning to manage the tax impact.
- Transfer Because of Death – Whoever receives the installment obligation as a result of the seller’s death is taxed on the installment payments the same as the seller would have been had the seller lived to receive the payments. An installment note does not receive a step up in value based upon the seller’s death.
If, however, an installment obligation is canceled, becomes unenforceable, or is transferred to the buyer because of the death of the holder of the obligation, it is considered a disposition. In this situation the estate must figure its gain or loss on the disposition. If the holder and the buyer are related, the fair market value of the installment obligation is considered to be no less than its full face value.
- Business Installment Sales – Installment sales can also be used when a business is sold. Essentially, the same rules apply, but complexity arises when the sales price is composed of different assets, for example business equipment, real property, and goodwill.
The installment sales method offers a flexible and tax-efficient strategy for selling rental properties, allowing sellers to spread their tax liability over the period payments are received. However, it requires careful consideration of various factors, including depreciation recapture, the calculation of the contract price and gross profit percentage, and the potential risks and benefits. Proper planning can help maximize the advantages of the installment sales method while minimizing its drawbacks.
Contact this office with questions and assistance.